Robert Kegan talks about how each successive developmental stage to which
one is subject has the previous stage as its object.  For example, at stage
3 you are socialized and you can only recognize how your socialization was
determining your life when you're at stage 4 and you can then look back on
your previous lifeworld when you were wrapped up with socialization and you
lacked the reflective insight that would have been necessary to keep you
from simply going along with the crowd and constantly worrying about what
your peers thought of you.  You can transcend this at the self-authoring
stage 4.  Thus, Kegan says that stage 3 is the object of stage 4.

 

This usage of subject and object is a little confusing for me.  It seems
that both phenomena that Kegan describes are subjective.  I figure the best
benchmarks for what "objective" means come from science and journalism.  If
we are talking about different sorts of subjective experiences then the word
"object" seems inappropriate.

 

As an alternative way of talking about similar phenomena, I want to draw
from Vervaeke's distinction between participatory knowing and perspectival
knowing. These are 2 of the 4 P's of knowing.  (The other two are procedural
and propositional, but they are less relevant to this matter at hand)
Participatory knowing is the ground of being, but we need to periodically
step outside and reflect on it and develop a perspective on it.  This moves
from participatory knowing to perspectival knowing.  To relate this back to
Kegan, if you are in the socialized self stage 3 then you are participating
in socialization.  At stage 4, you have a perspective on that prior stage
because you are now at the self authoring stage.  

 

What do you guys think?  Several of you are more experienced at these
matters than I am, but I'm just trying to work out clearer language here.
Your comments are welcome.

 

Thanks,

Brandon

 


############################

To unsubscribe from the TOK-SOCIETY-L list:
write to: mailto:[log in to unmask]
or click the following link:
http://listserv.jmu.edu/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=TOK-SOCIETY-L&A=1